Clean sheets are crucial and there have been plenty of match-saving goalkeepers to have played in the Premier League – but who is the greatest?
That was the subject discussed by Gary Lineker, Alan Shearer and Ian Wright on the latest edition of the Match of The Day: Top 10 podcast and we asked you to get involved by ranking your favourites from a shortlist drawn up by the Match of the Day commentary team.
More than 160,000 of you made your selections, and the result is below (result correct as of 08:30 BST on Sunday, 5 March).
To hear the MOTD team’s final selections – recorded during a debate held in Lineker’s kitchen, before the coronavirus outbreak in the UK – make sure you watch Match of the Day: Top 10 on iPlayer.
1. Peter Schmeichel
Premier League appearances: 310
Clean sheets: 128
Lineker: “He was the best goalkeeper I played against in my time, a phenomenal goalkeeper and made the ‘starfish’ save. What an unbelievable career.”
Wright: “I only scored against Schmeichel in friendlies. He was the only goalkeeper I thought about before I went into a game because he was so good. I genuinely hated him as a goalkeeper. I knew how good he was and how it was to score against him. Christopher Wreh scored against Schmeichel – people don’t even know who he is – and I didn’t manage to do it.”
2. Petr Cech
Premier League appearances: 443
Clean sheets: 202
Lineker: “Cech kept clean sheets in nearly half of the Premier League games he played in. He won four Golden Gloves, four Premier League titles, the Champions League, five FA Cups, three League Cups, the Europa League and was the Czech footballer of the year nine times.
3. Edwin van der Sar
Premier League appearances: 313
Clean sheets: 132
Lineker: “Van der Sar shows you the importance of a good goalkeeper in the modern game because Manchester United took a long time to replace Schmeichel.”
Shearer: “We keep going on about Alisson and Ederson and how they have changed goalkeeping, Van der Sar could play, no doubt. He could pass a ball.”
Wright: “1,311 minutes without conceding a goal, a world record.”
4. David Seaman
Premier League appearances: 340
Clean sheets: 140
Lineker: “He is the most laid back goalkeeper I have met in my life. He made one of the best saves ever from me, I was three yards out and the ball came across and bang, hit it, but he just came across from nowhere and it was unbelievable. You would never congratulate the goalkeeper after, it was sickening but he deserved credit after that one, my god what a save.”
Wright: “From the time he came into the dressing room, Seaman was so calm and he made the rest feel that way. Him being in goal on a daily basis, telling me where to go, when a goalkeeper will close in with a bad touch, I know I would not have scored as many goals as I did without playing with a keeper of that calibre.”
5. David de Gea
Premier League appearances: 304
Clean sheets: 108
Shearer: “When he first came to England he was open to a lot of criticism because he not that big, he had not bulked up and made too many mistakes. Then he went through that period where he was fantastic and made some incredible saves. At the moment, he is making too many mistakes and goalkeepers are often judged on how many mistakes they make.”
Wright: “The period that Manchester United have been through over the last three or four years, I do not know where they would be without him.”
Lineker: “Some of the saves he has made have been extraordinary.”
6. Alisson
Premier League appearances: 58
Clean sheets: 31
Lineker: “He has been unbelievably good for Liverpool, has made a massive difference to their team and transformed things for the team. He is a goalkeeper that exhumes calmness which is very important.”
Shearer: “Alisson and Virgil an Dijk have been the game changers for Liverpool. On the pitch, they are the ones that have made the difference.”
7. Ederson
Premier League appearances: 99
Clean sheets: 45
Wright: “He has been amazing for Manchester City. Not only has he won trophies, he is one of the goalkeepers that has changed the position for the way keepers have to be now.”
Shearer: “Some of the passes this guy comes out with, he is better than some of the players I have played with.”
Wright: “When he was younger, Ederson played left-back, you could easily see him playing left centre-half now with the way he pings the ball about. He has great footballing ability.”
8. Jens Lehmann
Premier League appearances: 148
Clean sheets: 54
Wright: “He was one of the leaders in the dressing room. He had a bit of something (an edge) about him but also a mistake in him, maybe someone you couldn’t trust one million percent.”
9. Shay Given
Premier League appearances: 451
Clean sheets: 113
Wright: “Given was a good shot-stopper and had athletic ability, but he was somebody I fancied it against.”
Shearer: “He wasn’t great at kicking, which is a huge part of the game now, but he worked hard and was a brilliant professional.”
10. David James
Premier League appearances: 572
Clean sheets: 169
Shearer: “He made hundreds of appearances and had great longevity. To be around for that amount of time, you have to be a good goalkeeper.”
